Comparing metal roofing vs asphalt shingles for your Iowa home? Asphalt shingles generally cost less upfront, while metal roofing may offer a longer service life at a higher initial price. The right choice depends on the specific products, your roof’s condition, your budget and how long you plan to own the home.
At All American Exteriors, we install both asphalt shingles and metal roofing for homeowners in Indianola, Des Moines and surrounding Central Iowa communities. Our roof installation services give you a place to start when comparing materials for a replacement roof or new construction.
Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles: How Do They Compare?
| Compare | Metal Roofing | Asphalt Shingles |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Usually higher. Varies by metal, finish and installation. | Usually lower. Varies by product and project scope. |
| Lifespan | Can last longer with proper installation and care. | Depends on product, installation, weather and care. |
| Style | Metal panels and stone-coated steel options. | Multiple colors and dimensional styles. |
| Storms | Product ratings matter. Hail can dent or damage metal. | Product ratings matter. Impact-resistant options are available. |
| Upkeep | Check flashing, fasteners, penetrations and finishes. | Check shingles, flashing and signs of wear. |
| Selection | Compare the specific system and installation requirements. | Compare the specific shingles and installation requirements. |
Which Roof Costs Less in Iowa?
Asphalt shingles are usually the more affordable option at installation. Metal roofing generally requires a larger upfront investment, but the difference depends on the systems being compared. A basic exposed-fastener panel, standing seam roof and stone-coated steel roof can have different material and labor requirements.
For either material, roof size, slope, tear-off, flashing and decking repairs influence the final price. Our roof replacement cost guide explains factors to consider before budgeting. A property-specific estimate is more useful than a generic price that leaves out the condition of your home.
What Roofing Options Does All American Exteriors Offer?
We offer asphalt shingle and metal roofing options. Our Indianola roof replacement page identifies materials including Boral stone-coated steel and shingles from CertainTeed, Malarkey and Atlas. Ask which current products are available and suitable for your project.
Stone-coated steel is a metal roofing option with a different appearance from the long metal panels many homeowners picture. When comparing choices, look at actual product samples and our recent exterior projects. Consider how the roof will coordinate with your siding, trim and the overall style of your home.
Which Handles Iowa Hail and Wind Better?
There is no automatic winner based on material alone. Compare the impact and wind ratings of the exact roofing products, along with their installation requirements. Both metal and asphalt roofs can sustain storm damage.
If hail resistance is a priority, review our guide to Class 4 shingles in Iowa. A Class 4 rating reflects performance in a specified impact test. It does not make a roof hail-proof or guarantee that every storm will leave it undamaged.
If you are comparing materials because your current roof was damaged, start with an assessment of what happened. Our storm damage services and storm damage roof repair guide explain the next steps before you decide on repairs or replacement.
Does Metal Roofing Last Longer?
Metal roofing can provide a longer service life than asphalt shingles, but the product and installation matter. Flashing details, roof penetrations, weather exposure and ongoing care all influence performance. Compare the complete roofing systems rather than choosing from a lifespan claim alone.
Also separate expected service life from warranty coverage. Material defects, workmanship, storm damage and cosmetic changes may be treated differently. Our 50-year roofing warranty explanation outlines questions to ask. Confirm the written terms for the specific roof being proposed.
What About Winter and Maintenance?
Both roofs need periodic checks. Asphalt shingles should be checked for damage, missing sections and wear. Metal roofing needs attention to flashing, penetrations and the fastening or coating details applicable to its design. Our fall roof inspection guide covers concerns to address before colder weather.
A new roof covering alone will not fix every ice-dam problem. Attic air leaks, insulation and ventilation may also need attention. Snow sliding from metal roofing should be considered around entrances and walkways. Drainage matters with either material, so include the condition of your gutters in the project discussion.
Which Material Fits Your Home?
Asphalt shingles may fit your priorities if you want a lower initial cost and a familiar residential appearance. Metal roofing may be worth the additional investment if you prefer the available styles and are planning around long-term ownership. Neither choice should come before understanding your roof’s condition.
For example, a homeowner with isolated missing shingles may need a repair assessment rather than an immediate material upgrade. A homeowner already planning a complete replacement can compare both systems using the same roof measurements and repair scope. Our roof inspection services help establish that starting point.
Who Installs Metal and Shingle Roofs in Central Iowa?
We do. All American Exteriors provides asphalt shingle and metal roof installation, with roofing services for Indianola homeowners, Des Moines homeowners and surrounding communities. Explore our Central Iowa service areas for more local information.
When comparing metal roofing vs asphalt shingles, bring us your questions about cost, appearance, storm performance and maintenance. Call (515) 255-4872 or request a free roofing estimate so we can discuss your home and the options available.
Common Questions
Is metal roofing worth the extra cost in Iowa?
It can be, depending on the proposed system, your budget and how long you plan to own the home. Compare installed cost, maintenance requirements, appearance and written warranty terms against the asphalt shingle option.
Are Class 4 asphalt shingles hail-proof?
No. Class 4 identifies performance in a specified impact test. It does not guarantee that shingles will avoid damage in every hailstorm.
Does All American Exteriors install metal roofing?
Yes. All American Exteriors offers metal roofing and asphalt shingle installation for homeowners in Indianola, Des Moines and surrounding Central Iowa communities. Ask which products are available for your project.
Do I need a full roof replacement if shingles are missing?
Not always. An inspection can help determine whether the damage is limited enough for repair or whether the roof’s overall condition supports replacement.
How do I get a roofing estimate in Indianola or Des Moines?
Call All American Exteriors at (515) 255-4872 or use the website’s estimate request form. Discuss your roof’s condition, preferred materials and project priorities to request a property-specific estimate.